If singular they has deep historical precedent, then it is dispositive on the sub-question of what is traditionally correct.[…] Putting the referent in the plural – “All the students aced their projects” – nixes the troublesome (grammatically singular but semantically plural) each student.Read on. You know you want to.
I first heard the singular they on The Archers when I was 12. Someone
somewhere in Ambridge had done something wrong and the speaker growled, “When I
find out who it was, they’ll be sorry.” Which neatly avoided ascribing a sex to
the offender. How useful, how convenient, I thought then and I still do. Avoids
all that “he or she” nonsense which the Economist rightly condemns as “ugly and awkward”.
5 comments:
The 's/he' nonsense is awkward. There was a woman (and see, off topic, but I'd rather use lady there, it sounds gentler, friendlier, to me, however to do so then distracts attention to assumptions about me, over what it is I'm saying) on Twitter who wanted to know if there is a novel written only using gender neutral pronouns.
I thought possibly Ursula Le Guin, though haven't read enough of her to name an instance, quite possibly a short story by Pat Cadigan, and Margaret Atwood would be most likely to in the future.
But can anyone name one?
As a former teacher (I couldn't keep up with the paperwork) I used 'they' instead of 'he or she' quite often, but always felt I was letting the side down. Not that anyone would have noticed through the other teacher's hazes' of mi'splaced apostrophe's'.
I am disinclined to take writing advice from anyone who produces a quote link the one you've used. Even though in this case I agree with them.
@Mark, I have no idea. Possibly someone French. Or Canadian.
@Katherine, you were right and they were wrong.
@helenalex, the Economist is actually a really useful non-pedantic guide to current usage - and sometimes they take the piss a bit. It can be hard to tell.
L really appreciated the link, and passed it on to my colleagues - we write instructional guides - and the key principles can never be stressed too often. I must admit my pet peeve is the number of them (colleagues) who suffer from apostrophe syndrome and semi-colon disease.
But then, they are Australians!
Or am I just a pedant?
PS I've used 'they' for years as the other is just too silly, and definitely too PC.
Post a Comment